A scrap car offer can look like a number pulled from the air. It is not. Three things produce it: how much the vehicle weighs, what its parts are worth to other drivers, and what the metal market is paying. This guide takes each one apart so that you can understand an offer, and tell a serious one from a careless one.
Factor 1: weight
Why weight comes first
When every reusable part has been removed, what is left of a vehicle is metal, and metal is sold by the tonne. The heavier the vehicle, the more there is to sell. This is the part of the offer that exists whatever the condition of the car.
Curb weight
The figure that matters is the curb weight: the vehicle as it stands, with its fluids but without passengers or cargo. You will find it in the owner’s manual, on the manufacturer’s specification sheet and often on the label in the driver’s door frame.
As a rough order of size:
| Type | Relative weight |
|---|---|
| Subcompact car | Lightest |
| Compact car | Light |
| Mid-size sedan | Medium |
| Minivan, mid-size SUV | Medium to heavy |
| Full-size pickup, large SUV, cargo van | Heaviest |
Not all of the weight is metal
A vehicle also contains glass, plastics, rubber, foam, fabric and fluids. None of that is paid for as metal, and some of it costs money to handle. A recycler’s price per vehicle takes this into account; it is one reason an offer is not simply “weight times the price of steel”.
What is in the mix
- Steel and iron. The bulk: body, frame, engine block, suspension.
- Aluminum. Wheels, some engine parts, radiators, and on some vehicles body panels. Worth more per kilogram than steel.
- Copper. Wiring, starter, alternator, electric motors. Worth much more per kilogram, but there is little of it.
- Precious metals. Small amounts in the catalytic converter.
A vehicle with aluminum wheels and an aluminum engine is worth a little more than its weight alone suggests.
Factor 2: parts
Reuse beats recycling
A working alternator is worth far more as an alternator than as a few kilograms of copper and aluminum. Wherever a part can serve again, it adds to the offer.
The parts that count most
- Engine and transmission, when they work.
- Catalytic converter. Valuable for its precious metals even when the car is dead.
- Transfer case, differentials and axles on trucks and SUVs.
- Body panels: doors, hood, fenders, tailgate, when straight and rust-free.
- Wheels and tires.
- Headlights, tail lights, mirrors.
- Electronic modules, airbags that have not deployed, seats and interior parts.
What decides whether parts add value
Demand. Parts for models that are common on Quebec roads sell quickly. Parts for a rare or very old model may never find a buyer.
Proof. A drivetrain that can be started and tested is worth more than one that must be taken on trust. This is why a running car is worth more than an identical one that does not run.
Condition. A door with rust in its lower edge is metal, not a part.
What failed. A car retired for structural rust usually has a healthy drivetrain. A car retired for a seized engine has good body panels but no engine to sell.
Completeness
Missing parts are counted twice: once for the part itself, once for what its absence says about the rest. A car without wheels is also harder to load. Removing the battery, the wheels or the converter yourself nearly always costs you more than those parts bring.
Free towing, 7 days a week. Paid on the spot.
Factor 3: the metal market
A world market
Scrap steel, aluminum and copper are commodities. Their prices are set by supply and demand far beyond Quebec: construction activity, manufacturing, energy costs, trade rules and exchange rates all play a part. A recycler sells into that market and can only pay owners in proportion to what it receives.
What that means for you
- Offers change over time. A neighbour’s figure from two years ago tells you little.
- Offers are similar on a given day. Serious recyclers face the same market, so their offers for the same vehicle tend to be close. A figure far above the others deserves a question about what happens at the door.
- You cannot time it. Movements are unpredictable, and for a single vehicle they are small compared with the cost of keeping it.
The exchange rate and other influences
Metals are largely priced in American dollars, so the value of the Canadian dollar matters. So do fuel and transport costs, since scrap is heavy to move. None of this is visible to the owner; it simply explains why prices drift.
How the three combine
Think of the offer as a sum.
- Start with the metal value for the vehicle’s weight at today’s market.
- Add for a drivetrain that works, parts in demand, alloy wheels, a complete vehicle.
- Subtract for missing parts, fire or flood damage, or a model nobody needs parts for.
- Allow for the recycler’s costs: towing, depollution, handling of tires and fluids, labour.
The result is one figure. With us, towing is free and nothing is deducted for it afterwards.
Two examples
A twelve-year-old compact sedan, failed inspection for rust, runs well. Light, so the metal value is modest. But the engine and transmission work, the model is common and the car is complete. The parts lift the offer above its metal value.
A fifteen-year-old full-size pickup with a seized engine. Heavy, so the metal value is high. The engine adds nothing, but the transmission, transfer case, axles, box and doors are in demand. It will be offered more than the sedan despite not running.
Change one detail in either, such as a missing converter, and the figure moves.
What does not enter into it
- What you paid for the car.
- What you spent on recent repairs, unless a major component is nearly new.
- Sentimental value.
- A full tank of fuel.
- Aftermarket accessories, which are worth more sold separately.
How to make your offer accurate
The recycler prices what you describe. Give:
- make, model and year;
- whether it starts and whether it moves;
- what failed;
- what is missing, without exception;
- the type of wheels;
- where it is and how easy it is to reach.
If you are unsure about something, say so. A firm price built on a wrong assumption is what produces a revised price in the driveway.
Questions to ask about any offer
- Is this price firm for the vehicle as I described it?
- Is towing included, with nothing deducted?
- When am I paid?
- Will I get a receipt?
For more on comparing offers and avoiding tricks, see cash for junk cars and our guide on how much a scrap car is worth.
How a buyer sizes up a car in two minutes
Understanding the buyer’s mental checklist explains most offers. From your description, an experienced buyer is answering six questions in order.
1. How heavy is it? The body type and the model give the weight, and the weight gives the minimum. 2. Is it complete? Engine, transmission, catalytic converter, wheels, battery. Each missing item lowers the figure. 3. Does the drivetrain work? A car that starts and moves has an engine and a transmission that can be resold with confidence. 4. Is anyone looking for parts from this model? Common models on Quebec roads have steady demand; rare ones do not. 5. What condition is the body in? Straight, rust-free panels are worth removing. Rusted or crumpled ones are metal. 6. How hard is it to collect? A car in a driveway is one thing; a car without wheels behind a shed is another.
The offer is the sum of those answers, less the cost of collecting, draining and dismantling the vehicle. Nothing in the list concerns the paint, the cleanliness of the interior or what you paid for the car.
Part by part: what adds value and what does not
| Component | Adds value when | Adds little when |
|---|---|---|
| Engine | It runs, or ran until recently, on a common model | It is seized, cracked or from a rare model |
| Transmission | It shifts properly | It slips or has failed |
| Catalytic converter | Original and present | Missing, or an aftermarket replacement |
| Body panels | Straight and free of rust | Rusted through or damaged |
| Wheels and tires | Alloy wheels, recent tires | Bare steel wheels, worn or flat tires |
| Battery | Present | Missing |
| Interior | Clean seats and trim on a sought-after model | Stained, torn, mouldy |
| Electronics | Working modules, screens, sensors | Water-damaged |
| Airbags | Intact | Deployed |
| Glass and lights | Intact, especially headlights | Broken |
| Accessories | Factory-fitted items in demand | Aftermarket stereo, tinted glass, decorative parts |
Aftermarket accessories are the usual disappointment. A sound system, a body kit or custom wheels that cost a great deal rarely add anything to a recycler’s offer. If they are worth something to you or to another enthusiast, remove them before asking for the offer and say that you did.
What you can influence, and what you cannot
| You cannot change | You can change |
|---|---|
| The metal market that week | How completely and accurately you describe the car |
| The model’s popularity | Whether the car is complete when it is collected |
| The car’s age and mileage | How accessible it is |
| What has already failed | Whether the papers are ready |
| The distance and the equipment needed | When you sell: while it still runs, or after it has sat for two winters |
The right-hand column is short, but it is where the difference between a fair offer and a poor one is made.
Seven beliefs that cost sellers money
- “A newer car is always worth more as scrap.” Not if nobody needs its parts, or if it burned.
- “I should take the good parts off first.” The offer drops by more than the parts bring, and a stripped car is harder to place.
- “The catalytic converter alone is worth a fortune.” Values vary widely by model, and a car without it is worth much less. See catalytic converter value.
- “A full tank adds value.” It does not.
- “If I fix one thing, I will get more.” A repair on a car being recycled is money lost.
- “The highest offer on the phone is the best.” Only if it is firm and free of fees. See how to choose a trustworthy scrap yard.
- “It will be worth more in the spring.” Nobody knows, and the car will be in worse condition.
Why two yards quote differently for the same car
A spread between offers is normal and does not mean someone is dishonest.
- Their outlets differ. A yard that sells many parts for your model values the car more than one that sends most vehicles straight to metal.
- Their stock differs. A yard that already has three of your model needs a fourth less.
- Their costs differ. Distance, equipment and labour vary.
- Their assumptions differ. One buyer assumed the converter was original; the other was told it was replaced.
- Their conditions differ. One includes towing; the other deducts it.
Give each the same complete description and compare the amount you will actually receive.
A script for the phone
Read this, filling in the blanks, and you will have given a buyer everything needed for a firm offer.
After the offer
- Note the amount, the name of the person and the date.
- Confirm the pickup window and what you need to have ready. See the pickup checklist.
- Do not change the car between the offer and the pickup.
- If something changes, a flat tire, a part taken off, a dead battery, say so before the truck leaves the yard.
Related guides
These guides cover the questions that usually come up next.
- Catalytic Converters: Value and Theft. Why catalytic converters are valuable, which vehicles are targeted by thieves, how to protect yours, and what a missing converter does to a scrap car offer.
- How Much Is a Scrap Car Worth. Why there is no single scrap price, where cars, SUVs and trucks sit in the range, what raises or lowers an offer, and how to get a firm figure for your vehicle.
- Discarding a Vehicle With the SAAQ. Mise au rancart explained: when you can discard a vehicle, what you need, how to do it in SAAQclic or at an outlet, the plate, refunds and proof.
- Prepare a Car for Pickup. A step-by-step checklist for scrap car pickup day in Quebec: papers, emptying the car, access for the tow truck, the handover, the plate and what to do right after.
- Choose a Trustworthy Scrap Yard. Seven things a reliable scrap yard does, the warning signs, how to avoid a price drop at the door, and the questions to ask before you sell a scrap car in Quebec.
- Repair or Scrap. A three-number test for deciding whether to repair or scrap a car, the costs people forget, the faults that usually end a car, and what to do either way.
- What Happens at a Scrap Yard. From check-in to the steel mill: how a scrap yard drains, dismantles, crushes and recycles a car, how long it takes, and what happens to your belongings and data.
All thirty guides are listed on the guides page.
Frequently asked questions
What decides the price of a scrap car?
Its weight in metal, the value of its reusable parts and the current price of metal.
Why is my heavy old truck worth more than a newer small car?
Because it contains more metal and its drivetrain parts are in demand.
Does the catalytic converter really matter?
Yes. It contains precious metals and is one of the most valuable single parts on a scrap vehicle.
Why did the offer change from last year?
Metal prices move with world markets, and offers follow them.
Do recent repairs raise the price?
Only if a major component, such as the engine or transmission, is recent and works.
Should I strip parts to sell separately?
Generally no. Missing parts lower the offer by more than they bring.
How Montreal Auto Recyclage can help
We buy end-of-life vehicles across Greater Montreal, tow them for free and pay you on the spot, seven days a week from 7 a.m. to 8 p.m. You receive a receipt to use for your paperwork. To go further, see scrap car removal, cash for junk cars, the FAQ, our service areas and our other guides. Call 514-613-5005 or ask for a free quote.
Free towing, 7 days a week. Paid on the spot.